Google Gets a Get-Out-Of-Jail Card in Sonos Showdown

In a legal twist almost as surprising as a plot twist in your favorite TV series, a federal judge in California has done the unthinkable: thrown out a $32.5 million victory for Sonos against Google. It's like watching the underdog team score a goal in the last minute, only to have it disallowed by a controversial referee decision.

The Patent Tussle

This entire saga began in 2020 when the audio giant Sonos decided to sue Google. They accused the internet titan of trampling on their speaker patents. It's like the Clash of the Titans, except in technology.

Fast forward to this year, and a federal jury in California found Google guilty of infringing on one of Sonos' patents. They were fined a whopping $32.5 million. It's like having your hand caught in the cookie jar, except the cookie was patented sound technology.

The Twist in the Tale

But wait, there's a twist. U.S. District Judge William Alsup decided that two of Sonos's patents were about as enforceable as a "Do Not Enter" sign on a playground. He found that Sonos had tried to make these patents look older than they were by linking them to a 2006 application. It's like convincing your parents that you're old enough to stay out late by faking your birth certificate.

According to Judge Alsup, Sonos did not file the patent applications until 2019. By then, the industry had advanced, and Google had developed its multi-room audio technology. It's like coming up five years late to a party with a dish of wet chips.

The judge stated unequivocally that this was not a case of an invention pushing the industry into uncharted territory. Instead, the industry was going about its business, with the occasional inventor claiming, "Hey, I thought of that first!" It's like claiming you invented sliced bread after everyone else has been cooking sandwiches for years.

The Reactions

Sonos wanted to be more thrilled about this turn of events. They called the ruling "wrong on both the facts and the law." It's like getting a quiz question wrong and insisting that the answer key is mistaken. They plan to appeal the decision and remain determined to hold Google accountable for patent infringement. It's like a classic Western standoff – Sonos vs. Google.

On the other hand, Google is presumably exhaling a sigh of relief large enough to inflate a hot air balloon. They've chosen to reinstate software functionality that was deleted due to the Sonos litigation. It's similar to tearing down barriers after a long siege.

Google revealed in a blog post that they will be bringing back software features for Nest speakers, screens, and Chromecast devices. Previously, they could only belong to one speaker group at a time. It's as if a pair of twins forced to be in different classrooms at school can finally hang out together.

According to Google, this move occurred because a federal judge ruled that two of Sonos' patents were unlawful. It's like winning a game of Monopoly and being told to give back your properties because of a rule no one knew existed.

The Future

So, what is the future of this technological rivalry? It's like an endless chess game, with both sides making moves and countermoves. Sonos will continue to make their argument, and Google will continue to innovate in the audio arena.

In the grand scheme of things, this legal twist is just another chapter in the ongoing battle between tech giants. It's like a soap opera where you can't predict what will happen next. One thing's for sure, though – the Sonos vs. Google saga is far from over, and the plot twists will keep coming.

Read next: Google's Passkey Takeover Predicts the End of Passwords (Maybe)
by Rubah Usman via Digital Information World